AllStar Car Sales in Sebring, FL Choose from 202 Vehicles!
Cars Under $20,000
Under $20k
Cars Under 25k Miles
Under 25k Miles
At AllStar Car Sales, we’re passionate about what we do, and only the best pre-owned vehicles make an appearance on our lot. Located at 2671 US Hwy 27 S in Sebring, we’ve built a premier one-stop shop where you can browse a multi-brand selection of vehicles, trade in your current vehicle & arrange financing. We do it all under one roof!
Whether you’re looking for a luxury sedan, an efficient EV, a powerful truck or a versatile SUV, we make the process simple, transparent, and stress-free from start to finish!
100% Transparent Pricing: What You See Is What You Pay
Buying a car should be exciting, not exhausting, which is why we operate under our honesty pledge—buying without pressure, games, or gimmicks. That means no addendum stickers tacked onto the window, no forced dealer add-ons you didn't ask for, and no surprise fees hiding in the paperwork at signing. This is the AllStar Way.
We even back our prices with an explicit Price-Match Guarantee—if you find a lower price on a comparable vehicle elsewhere, we're happy to match it. We believe in fair, transparent trade valuations with no prolonged haggling, and we provide a no-haggle quote in writing so you know exactly where you stand before making any decisions.
Backed by the 30+ Year Alan Jay Automotive Network
AllStar Car Sales isn't a standalone corner lot. We are backed by the full strength and reputation of the 30+ year Alan Jay Automotive Network. That connection gives our customers direct access to comprehensive, top-tier automotive resources, including dedicated in-house service and parts departments & a fully equipped collision center. Furthermore, the Alan Jay Pre-Owned Warranty applies to every vehicle under 100,000 miles on our lot.
Carefree Financing and Budget-Friendly Tools
We go out of our way to secure a finance plan that fits your budget by working with a wide network of lenders to assist customers across all credit histories. Before you even set foot on the lot, our website offers handy budget filters to help narrow down your search.
You can also stop by the dealership for a quick, in-person trade evaluation with our team and complete our Pre-Approval Application to lock in financing in minutes. If you ever run into questions, our knowledgeable team will offer personal service every step of the way.
After-Sale Service Care
Our relationship doesn't end when you drive your dream car off of the lot. Whenever you need routine maintenance or a full system inspection, you can bring it to one of our certified Service Centers. Simply call us at (863) 314-5300 to book a service appointment. From simple oil changes to major repairs, our factory-certified technicians treat your vehicle with the highest standard of care, using genuine parts and proven diagnostic tools.
Stop dealing with dealership games and experience "The AllStar Way" for yourself. Visit us today at 2671 US Hwy 27 S in Sebring or browse our live inventory online to find your next vehicle!
Google Reviews
Great group of people, They will make it happen! Go see Rick very professional.
I had such a great experience here, especially as someone going through the car loan process for the first time. I was honestly really nervous and didn’t know what to expect, but Ryan and Rick were incredibly patient and understanding from the start. They took the time to walk me through everything step by step, answered all my questions without making me feel rushed or overwhelmed, and made sure I actually understood my options. What stood out the most was how supportive they were. They really helped build my confidence in making this decision. Because of how comfortable they made me feel, I was able to come back with a co-signer and move forward without that same fear I had in the beginning. If you’re new to this process or feeling unsure, I definitely recommend coming here. They genuinely care about helping you, not just making a sale. 10/10 experience! I am so happy with my new vehicle and the service I received. Honorable mention: I had to go back to get my license plate situated and Ashley took care of me with no problem! all the staff here is so wonderful and nice, and just willing to help with whatever is needed. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone searching for quality service and vehicles.
Rick and Ryan were absolutely amazing to work with. I highly recommend them to anyone looking for a new vehicle. They made the process easy and enjoyable.
I had a great experience at All Star Car Sales and wanted to give a shoutout to Zach Williams for making the whole process smooth and stress-free. From the start, Zach was super easy to talk to—no pressure, no gimmicks, just honest help. He really took the time to understand what I was looking for and helped me find a car that fit both my needs and my budget. Any questions I had, he answered clearly, and he made sure I felt confident every step of the way. Buying a car can be overwhelming, but Zach made it feel simple and straightforward. If you’re heading to All Star Car Sales, definitely ask for him—you’ll be in good hands.
First of all, i have to say, Zach & Ryan are great! They helped me into a car that i needed not that I wanted because if I had got the car i wanted i would probably be unhappy, Zach listened to what I needed, down to every detail and found me the absolute perfect car, if that makes sense, anyway Both Zach & Ryan really understand the car business and are not pushy, which made me feel like I was actually being heard rather then just another sale! Props to them, I would recommend All-Star Carsales to anyone whos in the used car market, they will 100% work with you, I usually don't write reviews but, I'm that happy with my purchase and experience with them!
Got a great car at a great price, financing was good and overall the process was fast. Wish they had a location closer to me.
This place is amazing! Ashley and Patrick were so nice and helpful in finding a great car for me that exceeded my expectations! I would recommend this place to everyone who is in need of a great car!! Thanks so much you guys!!
Fabulous experience working with Matthew! Very knowledgable and easy to work with!
Great service! Happy with my purchase!! Ask for Matt, he is a great salesman
I worked with Matthew to get into my car. His help was excellent and I really appreciate how hard he worked to get me into this beautiful SUV! Thank you so much Matt! 100/10 recommend Matt for all of your vehicle needs!
Matthew was absolutely wonderful. Got me into a vehicle I really love. Great people. Really go the extra mile. Awesome place.
Get Directions To Our Dealership
Find the quickest route to our dealership in Sebring, Florida.
Popular Used Cars
- Used Kia K5
4 listings starting at $16,650
- Used Kia Soul
4 listings starting at $6,600
- Used Toyota Camry
3 listings starting at $10,656
- Used Cadillac CT5
3 listings starting at $29,494
- Used Mercedes-Benz E-Class
2 listings starting at $42,995
- Used Kia Forte
2 listings starting at $16,989
- Used Chevrolet Malibu
2 listings starting at $18,576
- Used Honda Accord Hybrid
1 listings starting at $14,995
- Used Nissan Altima
1 listings starting at $26,009
- Used Chevrolet Camaro
1 listings starting at $28,175
- Used Toyota Corolla
1 listings starting at $18,424
- Used Chevrolet Corvette
1 listings starting at $59,717
Popular Used Trucks
- Used Chevrolet Silverado 1500
10 listings starting at $22,519
- Used Ram 1500
7 listings starting at $26,095
- Used Ford F-150
5 listings starting at $22,995
- Used Ford F-250 Super Duty
4 listings starting at $38,841
- Used Nissan Frontier
4 listings starting at $25,122
- Used Ford Ranger
4 listings starting at $31,035
- Used GMC Sierra 1500
4 listings starting at $32,780
- Used Chevrolet Silverado 2500HD
4 listings starting at $42,021
- Used Ram 2500
3 listings starting at $34,014
- Used Chevrolet Colorado
3 listings starting at $19,991
- Used Toyota Tacoma 2WD
3 listings starting at $24,676
- Used Ford Maverick
2 listings starting at $24,897
Popular Used SUVs
- Used Chevrolet Equinox
13 listings starting at $19,988
- Used Chevrolet Traverse
8 listings starting at $24,320
- Used Chevrolet Trax
8 listings starting at $18,680
- Used Nissan Rogue
6 listings starting at $19,500
- Used Chevrolet Trailblazer
4 listings starting at $17,521
- Used Ford Bronco
3 listings starting at $27,986
- Used Ford Escape
3 listings starting at $18,685
- Used Kia Seltos
3 listings starting at $19,986
- Used GMC Terrain
3 listings starting at $20,994
- Used Nissan Armada
2 listings starting at $29,877
- Used Chevrolet Blazer
2 listings starting at $16,780
- Used Dodge Durango
2 listings starting at $20,309
Popular Used Vans
- Used Kia Carnival
3 listings starting at $26,680
- Used Kia Carnival Hybrid
1 listings starting at $45,780
Call AllStar Car Sales at (863) 296-2151